Skip to main content

Fifty shades of black(theindianexpress)


The compelling arguments against demonetisation as a policy instrument for tackling black money are now well-known. Demonetisation ignores the processes that produce black money as well as its biggest hoards in forms like foreign currency, gold or real estate; also, its toxic side-effects in terms of “collateral damage” are astronomically high. These reasons would be relevant if demonetisation were really an economic policy, but as many commentators have rightly pointed out, it is a political ploy rather than an economic initiative. There is nothing inherently wrong in this. Accusing elected governments of playing politics is like accusing fish of being wet. What matters is the kind of politics being played and its consequences for our society.

Ever since it came to power, the current regime has been trying to invent or promote issues that are media-friendly, impact large numbers and seem important — but lack clear criteria for determining success or failure. Once identified, these are presented first as sharp binaries of good versus evil and second, and most important, as the personal initiatives of he-who-must-be-named, the Great Leader. Examples include Swachh Bharat; the “Give it up” campaign on LPG subsidy; “Beti bachao, beti padhao”; Make in India and others.

However, it is now amply clear that demonetisation outstrips all of the above by a great distance. It affects all citizens directly and guarantees saturation media coverage. For the average Indian, the objective of rooting out black money is both plausible and fuzzy, with no obvious criteria for measuring success. Demonetisation is an ideologue’s blessing because dissenters can be instantly denounced as supporters of corruption. Lastly, even at the cost of flouting constitutional norms, this decision has been exclusively associated with Narendra Modi and no one else, not even the RBI governor.

As media reports attest, resentment against the rich is the primary emotion prompting people to give demonetisation the benefit of doubt. As someone at the post-morning walk addas in my neighbourhood park put it: “Ab raeeson ki bajegi!” (Now the rich are going to get it). A large swathe of the citizenry, from the poor to the affluent, is rejoicing at the supposed suffering of the super-rich. It is this resentful satisfaction that enables them to bear serious hardship or considerable inconvenience with remarkable fortitude.

Resentment has long been recognised by philosophers as a potent defence mechanism for powerless people enduring sustained suffering. But current forms of resentment-fueled fortitude are threatened by two main factors which the government must tackle to avert a mass revolt. The first challenge is to manage public perceptions, once the inevitable failure of demonetisation to significantly reduce black money becomes obvious. Its willingness to lower norms of public propriety suggests that the government may scrape through this test. But the second hurdle is much harder to overcome because it remains unrecognised, namely the unthinking escalation in the scope of “black”.

In the popular imagination, the phrase “black economy” conjures up a dark den, far from the well-lit “white” economy, where shadowy criminals somehow produce “black money”. Except the economically insignificant case of counterfeiting, black money necessarily implies black incomes. Only a small proportion of the goods and services through which black income is earned are themselves illegal, like drugs, bribes or hawala commissions. Except for the fact that it is hidden, the bulk of black income is in fact indistinguishable from its white counterpart since it is earned from the very same, perfectly legal activities.

In sum, the black economy is not a separate or even separable entity — it is simply the concealed portion of the white economy. The moral reach of “black” is greatly expanded when associated with the conflation of “concealed” with “unrecorded.” In India, a huge number of daily economic transactions are unrecorded, but only a small proportion is actively concealed. The vegetable seller, domestic servant, hair dresser or chaiwala run unrecorded operations, but not in order to earn black money. In its anxiety to cover up the self-created currency crisis, the ruling regime’s rhetoric disparages the cash economy, insinuating that it is a shade of black. At the same time, it is silent about the commissions and other costs involved in the transition to the digital economy which will make most micro-enterprises unviable. The patience of the poor is unlikely to survive the piling of insult on injury.

For the affluent at the other end of the stoically suffering spectrum, demonetisation is already a guilt-edged policy. This group recognises its own complicity in the black economy, but harnesses its state-stoked resentment against an imagined super-rich minority sitting on vast stockpiles of black money to rationalise its own minor hoards. Too much talk of digitisation will surely make it uncomfortable because its lifestyles depend on unethical euphemisms like “informal sector” and “unorganised labour”.

A large part of Indian affluence is really the masked dividend of an unequal society — our consumption is underwritten by sub-minimum wages, which cannot be legally recorded. It is therefore uncertain how far the campaign for digitisation will go. In any case, digitisation without accountability and transparency is a worse nightmare because it cedes enormous power to the state.

By trying to encash popular resentment against the unscrupulous rich, the Modi regime has embarked on a risky road. There is little reason to rejoice at the apparent morphing of the Hindu Hriday Samrat into the Raja of the Resentful.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Cloud seeding

Demonstrating the function of the flare rack that carries silver iodide for cloud-seeding through an aircraft. 
Water is essential for life on the earth. Precipitation from the skies is the only source for it. India and the rest of Asia are dependent on the monsoons for rains. While the South West Monsoon is the main source for India as a whole, Tamil Nadu and coastal areas of South Andhra Pradesh get the benefit of the North East Monsoon, which is just a less dependable beat on the reversal of the South West Monsoon winds.

SC asks Centre to strike a balance on Rohingya issue (.hindu)

Supreme Court orally indicates that the government should not deport Rohingya “now” as the Centre prevails over it to not record any such views in its formal order, citing “international ramifications”.

The Supreme Court on Friday came close to ordering the government not to deport the Rohingya.

It finally settled on merely observing that a balance should be struck between humanitarian concern for the community and the country's national security and economic interests.

The court was hearing a bunch of petitions, one filed by persons within the Rohingya community, against a proposed move to deport over 40,000 Rohingya refugees. A three-judge Bench, led by Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra, began by orally indicating that the government should not deport Rohingya “now”, but the government prevailed on the court to not pass any formal order, citing “international ramifications”. With this, the status quo continues even though the court gave the community liberty to approach it in …

India’s criminal wastage: over 10 million works under MGNREGA incomplete or abandoned (hindu)

In the last three and half years, the rate of work completion under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) has drastically declined, leading to wastage of public money and leaving villages more prone to drought. This could also be a reason for people moving out of the programme.

At a time when more than one-third of India’s districts are reeling under a drought-like situation due to deficit rainfall, here comes another bad news. The works started under the MGNREGA—close to 80 per cent related to water conservation, irrigation and land development—are increasingly not being completed or in practice, abandoned.

Going by the data (as on October 12) in the Ministry of Rural Development’s website, which tracks progress of MGNREGA through a comprehensive MIS, 10.4 million works have not been completed since April 2014. In the last three and half years, 39.7 million works were started under the programme. Going by the stipulation under the programme, close to 7…